There is No Such Thing as an Addictive Personality
by Thaddeus Camlin, Psy.D.
The concentration of misinformation in the world of addiction is as dense as osmium. One of the most well-known misconceptions in addiction is the idea of an addictive personality. I hear references to someone with an addictive personality all the time from professionals and lay folk alike. The idea of an addictive personality is reminiscent of an availability cascade, in that people talked about it long enough that it became “true.” The reality, however, is that scientific evidence does not support the concept of an addictive personality.
A Closer Look at the “Addictive Personality”
Anti-social and depressive behavior frequently accompany addictive problems, but the keyword is behavior. Behavior is not personality. According to research, no personality factors have been found to reliably distinguish so-called “normies” from so-called “addicts.” Some personality traits have been identified as precursors to addiction (e.g. low self-esteem, impulsivity, emotionality, risk-taking). However, there are many individuals who share such traits and do not experience addictive problems.
So if an addictive personality is but another ill-informed and unsupported concept in addiction, why does it persist? Perhaps the resilience of a baseless idea like addictive personality can be found in one of humankind’s favorite cognitive magic tricks – the confirmation bias. People want to believe that addiction is something some people “have,” rather than patterned behavior present in all of us. The addictive personality concept is appealing because it confirms a belief in the externalization of addictive problems.
Many of us are willing to sign on to just about anything that keeps our own behavior patterns out of the looking glass. If I only drink socially and refrain from drive-thru lunches then I don’t have an addictive personality and that means there’s no need to take a look at how I spend over 80 hours a week in the office. My brother though, he has an addictive personality – I remember him obsessively collecting Thomas the Train toys as a kid – so he just has to stay away from booze. When it comes to human behavior, simple explanations sound satisfying but rarely suffice. In many ways, mainstream addiction theory and treatment in the United States is a giant cesspool of confirmation bias and the concept of an addictive personality is but one of the big fat lily pads growing out of the reasonless riparian wetland on the rich and fertile banks of undiscerning belief.